After 4 years, Arteta still cannot achieve this against MU

Four years have passed, yet Mikel Arteta remains unable to break the “curse” named Michael Carrick, as Arsenal once again fell to Manchester United in a match that seemed more favorable than ever.

Rewinding to the 2021/22 season, Manchester United hosted Arsenal at Old Trafford during a turbulent period. At that time, the Red Devils had just parted ways with Ole Gunnar Solskjaer and Michael Carrick was appointed interim manager. Despite doubts, MU showed great resilience to defeat Arsenal 3-2. Bruno Fernandes shone with a goal, while Cristiano Ronaldo scored twice, reaching the historic milestone of 800 career goals, a legendary moment in world football.

Four years later, history repeated itself. On January 25, 2026, MU entered the match in a difficult, unstable state and were not highly rated. In contrast, Mikel Arteta’s Arsenal stood atop the Premier League, regarded as the top contender for the title.

However, on the pitch, all predictions became meaningless. Once again, Arsenal was defeated by Carrick’s Manchester United. It was no longer a shock, but a defeat they fully accepted. MU played tightly, disciplined, and sharp at decisive moments, while Arsenal, despite controlling possession, lacked creativity and courage during crucial phases.

Four years have passed, yet the familiar scenario repeats. An Arsenal team built with a strong squad, considered “formidable,” still bows to Manchester United led by interim manager Michael Carrick. This loss is more than just a match result; it reveals a harsh truth: conquering the Premier League has never been an easy path.

Arsenal may play beautifully, control the game, and even start the season as the number one title favorite. But when facing critical moments, what they lack is the resilience of a big club, which has helped their opponent Manchester United stand firm even during the most turbulent and challenging times. Against a team “changing managers mid-season,” the Gunners still could not dictate the outcome on their terms.

The defeat to Carrick once again raises serious questions for Mikel Arteta. He has built an Arsenal with identity and quality, but to truly reach the top, such as winning the Premier League, that is still not enough. The toughest league in the world demands not only talent but also coldness, experience, and mental toughness in every big match.

Leading the table is an achievement to be proud of, but maintaining that position after 38 rounds is the true measure of a champion. Arsenal has come close to glory many times but faltered at the most crucial moments. Until they overcome “tests of resilience” like Manchester United, Arteta’s dream of lifting the trophy will remain only potential.