Maguire openly stated that MU was 'not good enough' during Amorim's tenure.

Maguire's candid remarks reveal a major weakness in MU's play under Amorim, causing the team to frequently lose control and suffer consequences in critical defensive moments.

Manchester United is currently experiencing an impressive surge under the interim leadership of Michael Carrick. Four consecutive wins against Man City, Arsenal, Fulham, and Tottenham not only showcased 10 goals but also gave the impression that the "Red Devils" are rediscovering the identity they had lost for a long time. This streak has improved MU's position in the standings and revived fans' confidence.

In stark contrast, the period when Ruben Amorim was in charge from November 2024 to January 2026 is considered a dark time. MU rarely demonstrated stability or signs of a return to their peak form. A record of only 24 wins in 63 matches, equating to a 38.10% win rate, clearly reflects the tactical deadlock and ineffective team operation under the Portuguese coach.

Discussing the differences, Harry Maguire emphasized the biggest improvement was in their ability to defend the 16.5-meter box area. The English center-back admitted: “Previously, our penalty area defense was far from adequate; every time the ball entered the box, opponents had chances.” Conversely, under Carrick, MU has shown clear improvement: “In recent matches, the urgency level has been much higher… not just defenders, but midfielders and wingers also track back to help.”

Beyond defense, Maguire believes MU's tactical approach is now more flexible than before. He said the team can now proactively impose their style when in possession, yet remain dangerous without the ball: “We need to be comfortable controlling the game with the ball, but also know how to play without it and still pose a threat.” This has helped MU avoid the rigidity criticized during Amorim’s era.

Maguire cited the win against Man City as a prime example of this mindset shift: “After scoring first against Man City, we accepted some pressure and defended the penalty area calmly.” MU no longer panics under pressure but instead knows how to compact the team, maintain shape, and wait for counterattack opportunities.

The English defender believes Carrick is building a tactically versatile MU, knowing when to press, when to play a mid-block, or drop deep: “There will be times for full-pitch man-marking and intense pressing… and times when we are happy to keep a tight shape and punish opponents on the break.” If this momentum continues, MU can definitely climb higher in the league standings during the season's final stretch.